This $9 Ring Guard Solved My Most Common Engagement Ring Dilemma—Plus, 4 Others I Love

Everyone talks about their engagement, but no one ever talks about the unfortunate chance of your ring not fitting. While 3,000 feet above ground on a hot air balloon, my now-fiancé surprised me with a proposal and a beautiful ring that was too big, leaving me to cling to that new diamond for dear life and start my search for the best ring adjuster as soon as my feet landed back on the ground. Though I was embarrassed to go to the jeweler's about my little issue, they assured me that it’s common. Most people have this special event come as a surprise, so it’s normal for your partner to be a little off with the sizes.

As any newly engaged person, not wearing the ring was not an option. I was eager to show it off, and equally anxious not to lose it (not for nothing, it took me almost four years to get that thing in the first place!). Luckily, I could find several options on Amazon, which thankfully offered next-day shipping. I’ll admit, searching for a ring-tightener wasn’t hard, yet deciding on the right ring resizer that made sense for me and my ring felt daunting with so many choices out there promising to do the same thing. I knew I had to try out more than a few ring guards before settling on the best option. I had a few of my favorites on my doorstep the next day—keep reading to discover my top picks.

The Best Ring Adjusters

Eletiuo Ring Size Adjuster for Loose Rings, 60-Pack

Having this 60-pack of adjusters on hand helped me when I wasn’t positive about my correct size. Plus, with so many choices in this one pack, you can try on different styles and sizes. I personally drifted towards the spiral ring guard and found the C-spacer to be another good temporary fix, though it’s not ideal if you expect to take your ring on and off (to shower, wash your hands, or do dishes). I also became hyper-aware of it at the gym, hoping this adjuster wouldn’t fall off. 

Eletiuo Filled Metal Ring Guard Set for Loose Rings

I was most familiar with this type of ring guard before dealing with this problem, having visited jewelry stores that offered something similar to adjust a ring, so I felt comfortable working with this style. Although I was a bit nervous doing it myself, it was super easy and looked almost identical to what a jeweler would have done. 

Chrome Cherry Ringo, Invisible Ring Size Adjuster for Loose Rings

If you don’t have needle-nose pliers and feel like the metal guard is too complicated, this may be a better option. This is essentially the same concept, except it’s a clickable attachment that takes the stress out of fine-tuning your ring size. 

Ring Size Adjuster In 14k Yellow Or White Gold Filled

Still not convinced that these options will work for you? Don’t believe the clear is clear enough? Consider this Etsy ring adjuster, which seamlessly integrates with your ring. You will forget where the ring starts and the guard ends. 

More Engagement Ring Care Must-Haves

Diamond Drunk The Starter Collection

Connoisseurs Diamond Dazzle Stik

Lion Latch Travel Jewelry Box Case

Ring Thing Ring Holder Keychain